Who is a “Good” Student?

apple in a classroom
Photo Credit: Tom Gill. via Compfight cc

Every student in school has their own set of strength, weakness, and habits. According to Kumashiro’s stories, in his textbook Against Common Sense, a common sense “good’ student only considers certain characteristics as positive. This “good” students described conforms to the authority of the teacher and only speaks up to participate in class discussion. The “good” student poses no behavior issues and sits quietly. He/she is very respectful and does not speak out unless called upon. This student is dedicated to their studies and always submits his/her assignments on time. A “good” student takes much interest in everything that’s taught and finds nothing boring or pointless.

This image of a “good” student may sound great to some, but really restricts certain students. This image really privileges students who are exactly like this. A teacher who only see’s this as a “good” student will miss the creativity, energy, and originality that comes with non-“good’ students. Not only does this impact the students but also the methods and techniques used for teaching. A “good” students takes away chances of experiencing the random, yet very effective, discussions and questions that lead to crucial learning. If students never speak up and add their own opinion, many opinions and viewpoints that make up our world, both cultural and individual, are never heard. Having this idea of a “good” student, does more restricting and oppressing than it does good. This idea of the “good” student doesn’t allow students’ strengths and uniqueness to benefit the classroom. If every student was a “good” student, the world would be a very boring, unsuccessful place.


3 thoughts on “Who is a “Good” Student?

  1. paydenfraser

    Taylor, awesome blog post. I agree that the “good student” restricts many students. We often reward the good students and the kids that do not fit in to this mold unfortunately get left behind. We need to reward individuality!

    1. I completely agree! Individuality is what makes up our world- how else can we prepare our students for life outside of school then to work with everyone’s strength and uniqueness to promote growth. Thanks for the comment Payden!

  2. Pingback: Community of Learning (PLN) ECS 210 Assignment. | Payden Fraser's Portfolio

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s